58 Benjamin Street, Greenwich, Connecticut 06870

About this home

Exceptional just minutes from the beach, village shops and restaurants, Metro-North, and many of the neighborhood's most sought-after destinations. Set on a quiet street, this inviting single-family home offers the rare combination of privacy and convenience in coveted Old Greenwich. The home has been freshly updated with brand-new white quartz kitchen counters and new paint throughout most of the interior. Outside, enjoy a private, level backyard with a stone patio, ideal for relaxing or outdoor dining. Close to Old Greenwich Elementary School, the Eastern Greenwich Civic Center, golf courses, Upper Crust, Garden Catering, downtown Old Greenwich, and the Metro-North station. Rent includes 3-4 organic lawn fertilizer applications per year. Pets permitted with some restrictions. An exceptional opportunity to enjoy one of Greenwich's most desirable neighborhoods with the beach, village, schools, dining, recreation, and train all close to home.

Flood risk: check the FEMA flood map for this address.

Pets & Lease

Schools

Interior

Building & Exterior

Lot & Land

What's nearby

Distances are straight-line from the property, not driving or walking routes. Places data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Recent comparable rentals

The 5 closest recent leases to this home, nearest match first — same building where possible, then the surrounding streets, widening only when there is nothing closer. These are recorded lease prices from the MLS, not estimates. No automated valuation is shown, because what a home is worth depends on condition, layout and timing that a formula cannot see — call John at 203·883·3399 to read them properly against this home.

5 comparable rentals — median $5,995/mo, ranging $4,400/mo to $10,500/mo.

Within a 15-minute walk, leased in the last year
• 51 Forest Avenue Apt 1352 bd · 2 ba · 1,241 sq ft · 0.7 mi away
  $5,200/mo2025-09-24
• 51 Forest Avenue2 bd · 2 ba · 1,271 sq ft · 0.7 mi away
  $5,995/mo2025-12-19
• 51 Forest Avenue Unit 242 bd · 2 ba · 1,160 sq ft · 0.7 mi away
  $6,500/mo2026-08-03
• 51 Forest Avenue Unit 431 bd · 2 ba · 1,203 sq ft · 0.7 mi away
  $4,400/mo2026-06-05
Within about a mile and a half, leased in the last 2 years
• 124 Shore Road3 bd · 3 ba · 1,704 sq ft · 0.3 mi away
  $10,500/mo2024-11-05

More rentals in Greenwich

Closest in price to this one.

• 15 lafayette Court Unit 1B2 bed · 3 bath · 1,196 sq ft$7,000/mo
• 80 East Putnam Avenue3 bed · 4 bath · 1,934 sq ft$6,800/mo
• 15 River Road Unit 2052 bed · 2 bath · 1,270 sq ft$6,500/mo
• 1188 King Street Unit 1051 bed · 1 bath · 25,946 sq ft$7,500/mo
• 51 Old Kings Highway Unit 162 bed · 2 bath · 905 sq ft$7,500/mo
• 40 Ettl Lane Unit 233 bed · 4 bath · 2,364 sq ft$7,700/mo

← Back to all Stamford listings