Calf Pasture Island, Norwalk, Connecticut 06854

About this home

Opportunities like this are rare. Calf Pasture Island is one of just 10 private islands off the coast of Norwalk, offering a uniquely private coastal setting and a blank canvas for imagination. Properties like this remain in the same hands for many decades and do not come up for sale often. Located approximately a half mile offshore, it is among the closest islands to the mainland and takes its name from the cattle once kept there. The island is easily accessible from Norwalk Harbor and the Saugatuck River, making it a convenient yet distinctly separate retreat. A small A-frame structure currently sits on the island, and future development options may be explored. Shaped by retreating glaciers more than 17,000 years ago, the Norwalk Islands form a rare archipelago scattered across Long Island Sound. For generations, they have attracted boaters, kayakers, and those drawn to life just beyond the shoreline. Rich in maritime history and surrounded by protected waters, portions of the island chain fall within the Stewart B. McKinney National Wildlife Refuge, helping preserve the natural beauty, wildlife, and sense of escape that define this remarkable setting. A place for those who appreciate that true privacy often lies just beyond easy reach. Also for sale is Betts Island which is MLS #24148140.

Flood risk: check the FEMA flood map for this address.

Taxes

Interior

Building & Exterior

Lot & Land

What it would cost per month

An estimate you can adjust — not a quote, and not an offer of credit. Principal and interest only, plus the taxes and HOA already on this listing. Insurance, PMI and closing costs are not included. Rate seeded at 6.5% (August 2026); change it to whatever your lender quotes.

What's nearby

Distances are straight-line from the property, not driving or walking routes. Places data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Recent comparable sales

The 5 closest recent sales to this home, nearest match first — same building where possible, then the surrounding streets, widening only when there is nothing closer. These are recorded sale prices from the MLS, not estimates. No automated valuation is shown, because what a home is worth depends on condition, layout and timing that a formula cannot see — call John at 203·883·3399 to read them properly against this home.

5 comparable sales — median $1,006,500, ranging $940,000 to $1,600,000.

Within about a mile and a half, sold in the last 2 years
• 10 Island Drive3 bd · 2 ba · 1,617 sq ft · 1.1 mi away
  $1,600,000$989/sq ft2026-06-22
• 162 Gregory Boulevard3 bd · 2 ba · 1,426 sq ft · 1.2 mi away
  $949,000$665/sq ft2025-11-04
• 5 Elliott Street3 bd · 2 ba · 1,520 sq ft · 1.2 mi away
  $940,000$618/sq ft2025-09-19
• 13 Elliott Street2 bd · 2 ba · 1,287 sq ft · 1.3 mi away
  $1,010,000$784/sq ft2026-05-28
• 17 Marion Avenue4 bd · 1 ba · 1,500 sq ft · 1.3 mi away
  $1,006,500$671/sq ft2025-01-31

Recorded sales

Deed transfers on file with the Norwalk land records, newest first. These are recordings rather than MLS sales, so they include transfers that were never listed. Nominal and $0 transfers (estate, trust and family conveyances) are excluded.

• 2023-07-10$2,300,000Single Family

More homes in Norwalk

Closest in price to this one.

• Betts Island2 bed · 1 bath · 915 sq ft$3,500,000
• 30 Shorefront Park4 bed · 4 bath · 3,382 sq ft$3,450,000
• 3 Shorehaven Road5 bed · 6 bath · 5,481 sq ft$3,595,000
• 5 Wilson Avenue5 bed · 5 bath · 4,619 sq ft$3,595,000
• 60 Crooked Trail Road5 bed · 5 bath · 5,307 sq ft$3,395,000
• 9 Sylvester Court5 bed · 4 bath · 4,241 sq ft$3,295,000

← Back to all Stamford listings