434 Hurlbutt Street, Wilton, Connecticut 06897

About this home

Charming 18th-century antique Colonial set on 7.25 acres, offering exceptional historic character and an abundance of space. With approximately 3,410 square feet of living area, this distinctive five-bedroom, four-full-bath home features seven fireplaces, hand-hewn beams, wide-plank chestnut floors, and numerous built-ins throughout. Generously sized rooms and impressive ceiling heights enhance the home's spacious feel, while three separate stairways provide access to the second floor. The finished third floor offers two additional rooms, providing flexible space for a home office, recreation, or other uses. The driveway is shared with tenants of the cottage and barn. Landlord provides grounds maintenance and snow removal for added convenience. Ideally located in Cannondale, close to the train station, schools, and area amenities. A rare opportunity to enjoy the warmth, craftsmanship, and character of a historic New England home in a beautiful 7.25-acre setting.

Flood risk: check the FEMA flood map for this address.

Pets & Lease

Schools

Interior

Building & Exterior

Lot & Land

What's nearby

Distances are straight-line from the property, not driving or walking routes. Places data © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Recent comparable rentals

The 5 closest recent leases to this home, nearest match first — same building where possible, then the surrounding streets, widening only when there is nothing closer. These are recorded lease prices from the MLS, not estimates. No automated valuation is shown, because what a home is worth depends on condition, layout and timing that a formula cannot see — call John at 203·883·3399 to read them properly against this home.

5 comparable rentals — median $5,000/mo, ranging $3,400/mo to $6,000/mo.

Within about a mile and a half, leased in the last 2 years
• 529 Danbury Road Unit C1 bd · 2 ba · 3,886 sq ft · 0.8 mi away
  $3,400/mo2026-06-25
• 43 Blue Ridge Road Unit 23 bd · 2 ba · 2,920 sq ft · 0.9 mi away
  $5,500/mo2024-08-16
• 304 Olmstead Hill Road4 bd · 3 ba · 3,975 sq ft · 1.1 mi away
  $6,000/mo2026-06-01
• 21 Richdale Drive Unit A3 bd · 2 ba · 3,600 sq ft · 1.4 mi away
  $4,500/mo2026-08-01
Same town, leased in the last 3 years
• 7 Old Highway5 bd · 3 ba · 2,662 sq ft · 2.0 mi away
  $5,000/mo2024-09-26

Listing & sale history

Every time this exact home has come to market in the MLS data this site tracks. Where a sale closed, the recorded sale price is shown; "asking" marks a price the home was listed at rather than what it sold for.

Public record

From the Wilton assessor's public property record. These figures describe the property as the town has it on file and can differ from the listing — a finished basement or an addition may not be reflected in the assessor's living area.

Recorded sales

Deed transfers on file with the Wilton land records, newest first. These are recordings rather than MLS sales, so they include transfers that were never listed. Nominal and $0 transfers (estate, trust and family conveyances) are excluded.

• 2013-10-09$1,100,000Single Family

More rentals in Wilton

Closest in price to this one.

• 22 Hubbard Road Unit 3032 bed · 2 bath · 1,477 sq ft$5,225/mo
• 211 New Canaan Road4 bed · 3 bath · 3,292 sq ft$5,300/mo
• 65 Cherry Lane3 bed · 2 bath · 2,710 sq ft$5,300/mo
• 23 River Road Unit 21022 bed · 2 bath · 1,276 sq ft$4,811/mo
• 332 Belden Hill Road4 bed · 3 bath · 2,803 sq ft$5,800/mo
• 37 Wilton Crest Unit 372 bed · 3 bath · 1,934 sq ft$4,700/mo

← Back to all Stamford listings